WebAmerican Revolution vs. French Revolution. And it contradicts individual liberty when we reduce all relationships to individual liberty. Lastly, I will be concluding this discourse by stating the relevance of its implications to this very day. Sign in|Recent Site Activity|Report Abuse|Print Page|Powered By Google Sites. Historians have agreed the the French Revolution was an event that changed Europe irrevocably. King Louis XVI, Maximillian Robespierre, as well as the Jacobins, are one in the same, in their ignoble ways. Toussaint L'Ouverture, in particular, was deeply read in the French Enlightenment. Will you help us remain a refreshing oasis in the increasingly contentious arena of modern discourse? Retrieved from The relationship between those expanding West and the Indians is the same as between any high-tech society meeting a low-tech society in history. They were different in their causes, leadership, and effects. The difference between the American, Russian, and French revolution is the context in which they were caused by because each of them fought for their own struggles and had a different opinion on how their country was overseen and ruled. That may sound like an oxymoron to you, but you described what it was. In the United States, the Americans were fighting for freedom from the rule of Great Britain, which many people viewed as oppressive. Already a member? Haiti, under the rule of France, was one of the richest colony in the world with thousands of enslaved Africans working for sugar and coffee plantations, where as, Latin America, under the rule of Spain, had various people in different social classes, getting segregated. xsa*lXS. The friends were a country in the Americas Berry Colony. February 27, 2023 equitable estoppel california No Comments . Indeed, they even transformed Notre Dame into a Temple of Reason and held pseudo-religious festivals in honor of this new deity. That is, Americans fought for tangible goals; they fought to preserve their traditional rights rather than to overturn an established social order. Just like France, the American colonists were composed up mainly middle and lower class citizens. This success, along with several other causes, motivated the oppressed lower class of France to have their own revolution. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. What was the major difference between the American and French Revolutions? They were eager to question tradition and to change or dissolve the longstanding royal dynasties of Europe that had ruled via absolute monarchies for centuries. While whites always had the upper hand, during the revolution specific groups of people took over with rebellions and resistances. John Adams who signed the Declaration of Independence. The Imaginative Conservativeapplies the principle of appreciation to the discussion of culture and politicswe approach dialogue with magnanimity rather than with mere civility. They produced The Declaration of the Rights of Man, which embedded the ideas of equality, natural rights, and enlightenment into their ideal government. WebSimilarities Between the American and French Revolutions : Western Civilization II Guides. The American Revolution was the war between 13 colonies and the British Empire, whereas the French Revolution was the war between the people and the government. By understanding the individual stories of each country, you can further your understanding of the similarities and differences between the two. This only lead to an uproar of citizen fighting against the British Lobsterbacks and with the support of the French, America gained its independence. They are similar because the people who rebelled were ordinary citizens taking up arms and attacking their governments. One similarity is that in each revolution, people were fighting for freedom from some kind of oppressive rule, at least in the minds of those who were fighting for their freedom. WebThe differences in the revolutions in America and Haiti are far more numerous than any similarities. (Gifts may be made online or by check mailed to the Institute at 9600 Long Point Rd., Suite 300, Houston, TX, 77055. Individual liberty vs corporate liberty? Retrieved March 3, 2023 , from https://supremestudy.com/the-great-similarities-and-differences-between-the-french-and-american-revolutions/, This paper was written and submitted by a fellow student, Our verified experts write your 100% original paper on any topic. . Very similar to the American revolution the French disrespected the leadership of King Louis XVI, they believed his extravagant expenditure and participation in the American revolution left the country in poverty. Instead, it led them to descend into the Terror, the reign of Napoleon, and, ultimately, to the restoration of the monarchy. Both wanted to gain freedom and equality based on popular Enlightenment ideas/thoughts. WebBetween the years 1750 and 1914 the American Revolution the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolution. Was Winston Churchill a Nazi Sympathizer? The French Revolution and American Revolution are similar. Answers: 1. It is amazing! This is how these revolutions differ. Leon, The American Revolution was largely focused on preserving the unalienable natural rights of citizens. In France, their republic government system didnt stay in place like it did in America, therefore slowly drifting back into a monarchy. That made it the most fruitful slave revolt of all times. On the other hand, there were specific reasons to why people resisted and revolted against the leaders in charge. Constitution, The French Declaration provided for a national defense, and emphasized The CHOICE to engage in a trade relationship cannot be abused or manipulated, lest it ceases to be trade and becomes coercion. Both the Venezuelan and American revolution had the catastrophic number. Haiti was a French colony and was the first European colony in Latin America to undergo a successful revolution (1804). Though both revolutions have many relations, they both have many dissimilarities, throughout my work I will be displaying the reasons why both revolutions were similar and why they are different. The French and American revolutions were two revolutions that had the mind to change the government and to set up a democracy so that everyone could have equal rights. WebComparison between both revolutions was that, both were depended on equal rights, radicalism, thoughts from the awareness against dictator control, majority rule government; engaged by the victory of American transformation and depended on the statement of man from the French. In contrast, although Mexico did have conservatives that wished to stay a colony of Spain, the vast majority of people, regardless of social class, opposed the dictator. In both the United States and Haiti, the people were fighting for their freedom from an imperial power. In France, an official state Church was put in place. They had independence movements in which they fought for their freedom. Among his books are, A Conservatism of Joy, Gratitude, and Love, Patrick Henry-Onslow Debate: Liberty and Republicanism in American Political Thought, A Sober Desire for History: William Gilmore Simms as Historian, Luther Martin of Maryland & the Constitutional Convention. However, not only were there similarities, The time period during which both revolutions happen is relatively close, as both of these revolutions happen only about a decade apart, which is one reason for their similarities. There were representatives of each class at the meeting, but to try and produce a fair outcome, the third class requested the voting on action were taken all together instead of separately. That is what both colonial America, and France did. WebSimilarities between the French and American Revolutions Both want a change from being ruled by an absolute ruler, both have economic instability from war debt, both have social inequality. Jeremy, They created the Declaration of the Rights of Man, similar to the Declaration of Independence, listing grievances against the king. perfect equality would be inconsistent with liberty? That is definitely true but only for individual liberty, not corporate liberty. Latest answer posted October 06, 2019 at 11:40:56 AM. WebCompare American and French politics of the 18th and 19th centuries. What is george calvert's american colony. They also instilled The Bill of Rights to insure citizens would be treated equally and justly. Enlightenment ideas were spread in the Salons of Paris, and with the advent of Gutenbergs printing press, Enlightenment texts were printed in the vernacular and circulated widely. WebThere were many similarities and differences between the American and French Revolution. WebThe French Revolution and American Revolution were two examples of civilians rebelling against their government. Although it was considered to be over, the country was still uneasy after the death of Napoleon. "Situated as they were between the Spaniards and the masses. "Nonetheless, the Indians of New Spain (and elsewhere) enjoyed a set of legal privileges, exemptions, and protection which significantly interferes with their complete integration into colonial society, and kept them in a legal bubble of tutelage ruptured only with the advent of independent Mexican nationhood in the third decade of the nineteenth century (Van Young, 154). Both revolutions During the late 18th century, America a country ruled by The United Kingdom, had no control of the thirteen colonies. How was the Latin American Revolution different compared to Haitian, American, and the French? The American and French revolutions were two of the most significant revolutions in history. The colonists who rebelled didnt kill King George III, while in the French Revolution they were also rebelling against their ruler but unlike the American colonists they beheaded their king Louis XVI. We should also bear in mind that these revolutions were interrelated. Student Loans & the Presidents Power of the Purse, Conservatives, Liberals, & the Purpose of Education, Materialism: The False God of Modern Science. Enlightenment ideas began after the Scientific Revolution in Europe, when people began to question tradition. The people no longer marched in blasting away at each other. WebThe similarities of the American Revolution and the French revolution can be seen by examining the root causes, the rebels, and the lasting impact of both revolutions. The French and the American revolutions had similar causes. &'y+uqeLKyC`7G@&x,^WczodZqmqmQ@kUGMs{r{lv ntj^7V/H_GmVvTi]sn'T;zSB5CxJ>K>Sysn#"}NYsmW}+Bf#kD6,DYFCM-FZ-A{rR WebThe French and American Revolution has similarities and differences. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. Greene and Zinn argue that the years following Americas new found freedom consisted of the same type of oppression of Americans just. The French peasants were not represented by the Parliament. The American Revolution (1776) was the first revolution of the three. As for differences between the two, the American Revolution started with a limited monarchy, where as the French Revolution started as an absolute monarchy. Another difference is in the locations of these two countries. It was pretty clear that if the Haitians lost, slavery would return to Haiti. qv~Emm'^4]U~Y9$t X/>{H7A"FQ!a,700$d# %[|y0n,dnA #W,$:B'FE.#xC,Q=xLJP@[S,&7e%'` ~lfMHLBZ"L" %%,)jGn_luo1/ p-X 4dL4KNNrj,Qq<1{C$ # The political and social changes were more dramatic, however, as much as they changed, there were some parts of society that didn 't change, such as views on women and Native Americans., First of all, via the Sugar Act of the year 1764, the British government made an attempt to regulate trade tightly. The main difference between the American Revolution and the French Revolution is that the American Revolution was the war The French Revolution and American Revolution were the instances of civilians rebelling against their government. The French In the end the French lost the having to hand over, After years of battling the English both on and off the battlefield, America was finally crowned the victor. Note: The Americans created a Navy out of scratch whereas the French rebels afterwards used their government's ships to fight their wars. All comments are moderated and must be civil, concise, and constructive to the conversation. WebThe French Revolution and the American Revolution, had many similarities and differences. The outcomes of independence movements in Haiti and the Spanish Americas were similar because they both ended successfully and with independence from the colonizing nation, a difference however was that in Haiti the revolution ended with a complete social overhaul and the re-arrangement of social classes whereas in the Latin American revolutions it ended as mostly the same as before. The French are more conservative in this sense, since the decisions they take are still informed by a single common vision for the long-term good. The Haitian Revolution and the Latin American Revolution were revolutions that occurred in the 17th and 18th century, Mostly to obtain independence from their mother country. And the problem that exists for some conservatives is the notion of corporate liberty, it is the all-or-nothing thinking that comes with reducing all liberty to individual liberty. Later, the French Revolution came inspired by the Americans. The American Revolution and the Latin American Revolution were similar because they had similar motivations for the causes of their movements. Differences Between French, Russian and American Revolutions. 1. Again very good information! Another difference between the revolutionary processes in the two regions is that the American Revolution was successful and had stable and positive long-term outcomes, but the Haitian Revolution and Latin American Revolution were. And all-or-nothing thinking approaches to individual liberty leads to tyranny. In France, people revolted against the abuses of the French king and the very high taxes that the people had to pay. Here it is: Compare and Contrast Essay on the American and French Revolutions. The French Revolution and the Haitian Revolution are very similar in the ideals that drove them, the way they were carried out, and the things they achieved both through the revolutions themselves and their legacies today., However, this led to further uprising amongst the colonists such as the Boston Tea Party in 1773, which was the colonists attempt to abolish the Sugar Tax. Constitution, The French Declaration provided for a national defense, and emphasized equality before taxation which was distinctly different from traditional France, in which the Catholic Church and the nobility were exempt from most taxes. A revolution is to overthrow a government and replace with another. They were all part of the Age of Revolutionsa historical period (17741849) marked by a significant number of revolutionary movements inspired by the ideas of philosophes like John Locke, Baron de Montesquieu, Voltaire, and Beccaria. online. The Latin American revolution as well as the Haitian revolution were led to gain independence from the colonial power of France, Spain, and Portugal. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. Over taxation came from the 7 years war in which the British and French fought. France's Revolution followed America's Revolution, their desire for a free, fair Constitution strong. WebThe French and American revolutions had so many similarities as well as differences. Even though these two revolutions started out similarly they also had many differences, Some of the main differences were how the civilizations dealt with the revolution., Revolutions have been momentous events in modern world history erupting on every inhabited continent except Australia (Lockard). The Glorious Revolution of 1688 had transformed the government of Britain from an absolute monarchy into a limited monarchy where Parliament was superior to the monarch. A colony successfully won its own war against their mother nation, and became a newly formed independent country. The French Revolution lasted from 1789 until 1799. The Revolution precipitated a series of European wars, forcing the United States to articulate a clear policy of neutrality in order to avoid being embroiled in these European conflicts. Writers The American and French Revolutions were fought several years and an ocean apart. " eNotes Editorial, 7 Aug. 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-do-the-american-french-and-haitian-570689. Although the American and French Revolutions were fought over the same ideas, the American Revolution is considered more conservative than the French. The American revolution faired much better because they kept most of their power structure in place afterwards. The right to not be taxed without the consent of your elected representatives was one of the most prized rights of Englishmen. Thomas Jefferson the author of the Declaration of Independence. The similarities of the French Revolution and the American revolution was both sought a change for their government and economic conditions. Although the new government was not what the people had hoped for, the idea of a constitution that made all equal was created, fulfilling part of what the revolvers wanted (Kaplan). The French Revolution and American Revolution are similar. The American Revolution was mainly a political revolution while the French revolution was a mix of political, social, and an economic revolution. One of them is the fact that the American's had warships and the French rebels did not. In the American Revolution, American took control of their country from the British and gained their independence. Each revolution had liberty as its central goal, with both the Americans and the Haitian Revolutionaries struggling for independence from the mother country. That is what has continued to make America and the American Revolution stand out over the ages. This and other confrontations led the colonists to lose their patience, which eventually led to 12 representatives of the colonies meeting to discuss further action. It is also not remarkable, a straw-man argument, and it is a point that we need to move beyond. Even enlightenment philosophe Voltaire criticized the French monarchy and the Church considering them representatives of tyranny. Latest answer posted August 03, 2011 at 2:13:13 AM. The American Revolutionary War took place in thirteen colonies, in North America, an ocean away from its ruling monarchy in Great Britain, in Europe. Those creoles pushing towards revolution to free themselves from Spanish rule felt that the Spanish crown was only abusing, discriminating and holding them back form growing economically. An unprecedented event occurred that will change the world forever. After winning their independence Americans turned to the concrete lessons of history and experience to guide them in securing their liberty by establishing government on a solid foundation. The French had already discovered and claimed a massive region of North America, stretching from Louisiana in the South to the Canadian border in the north. That experience is the parent of wisdom, explained Hamilton, is an adage, the truth of which is recognized by the wisest as well as the simplest of mankind.[5]. In the same manner, the muskets and artillery were used to attack each other into submission. The signers of the Declaration did not think they were establishing a national government or founding a national Union when they signed it. In the same way American colonists were being taxed for every purchase of a British good. That shows that the two revolutions are the same. Accessed 4 Mar. The Declaration used Enlightenment ideas to bolster its list of grievances, mostly from Locke. Because the oppression in France of the third-estate was more systematic and supported by conservative first-estate and second-estate members, it was difficult to find a singular entity to blame the third-estates problems on; as a result, the National Assembly simply attacked, rioted, and protested those opposed to the movement. These two revolutions had many similarities and differences. Agree with everything the author said. The featured image is courtesy of Pixabay. Webbattled within the American War and returned to Saint Domingue, they had aims of shaping an unused society. Comparatively, the American Revolution ended on better footing. Revolutions were significant events in history that dramatically affected the rights of the inhabitants. One can see this by looking at France. Overall, there were many similarities between the American and French Revolutions. Latest answer posted February 03, 2021 at 6:26:14 PM. However, the French Revolution was about who should rule at home. WebDifferences in Start The Haitian's restraints were more severe and the rebellion was led by slaves with no rights at all. Between the years 1750 and 1914 the American Revolution the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolution. Yes, the second paragraph of the American Declaration of Independence deals in abstractions and universal truths. WebThe Colonies in America wanted free from under British rule but wanted to keep the laws and traditions they had acquired from England. This may have affected some decisions made by both in the revolutions as both had different outside influences. Both revolutions had similar reasons such as to become an independent Nation and secure liberal rights. Latest answer posted January 15, 2021 at 11:09:50 AM. Another reason as to why these differences occur is because their geography and their location is very different from each other. WebSimilarities Between the American and French Revolutions : Western Civilization II Guides. Kywrite, When it came to majority vote in America and in France, both groups who wanted change also wanted to ensure fair representation in either Parliament or in Estates-General. The following information will explain the two revolutions and how their actions created such a monumental change. The American and WebThe American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. He was very interested in Enlightenment thought and read the philosophes voraciously. How did the bravery and courage of men in America and France completely change the course of their countries future? The American and French revolution began because of the high taxes enforced upon middle and lower class people. Feeding the people became an issue, due to an unfortunate string of terrible harvests, which in turn forced food to take a steep rise up in price. Human reason, they knew, was fallible. One of the many differences between the American and French Revolutions is that, unlike the French, Americans did not fight for an abstraction. The French Revolution was an important age of political and social turmoil in France that lasted from 1789 to 1799. However they differed in that there was no goal for social reform in the American Revolution, but in the Haitian Revolution the slaves had the goal of social reform of the rigid social class system. With starting the revolution on a limited monarchy in Britain, the Glorious Revolution is what gave Parliament more power over the monarch, and some rights were given through the English Bill of Rights. Great job. Their actions will be remembered especially because having not done what they did, the country of America and the country of France would be completely different from what they are today. United States Declaration of Independence. Comparison between both revolutions was that, both were depended on equal rights, radicalism, thoughts from the awareness against dictator control, majority rule government; engaged This proposes the question of why is it easier to create a new government than to change an old one. When this became impossible to achieve within the British Empire, Americans declared their independence and then won it on the battlefield. How is it that France is so unsuccessful compared to the Latin American Revolution which had similar causes? Which then the rebellion led to violence amongst the government and the people. Under such a government, novel and untested, liberty would not be secure. With the exception, the Jacobins sought out for resolutions for the people, while King Louis XVI disregarded his people. They did this to permanently remove the power of Church authority within the government. This is significant because the French rebels did not have a navy as the Americans had a navy. The idea of nations breaking apart and forming new countries took the world by storm. France wished to debunk the unfair social stratification and the limited rights of the third-estate, ultimately leading to the abolishment of this oppressive regime, while Mexico wished to overthrow an oppressive dictatorship, which eventually ended in the endowment of unprecedented rights to the Mexican people. Eighteenth century Europe viewed governing a civilization through the means of power and control, rather than social and individual needs. Maximillien Robespierre the leader of the Reign of Terror in the French Revolution. Experience must be our only guide, John Dickinson reminded his colleagues at the Philadelphia Convention. The Causes of the French revolution and the American revolution are similar because they both were partially prompted by an over-reaching monarch, another similarity was that both revolutions were started by the commoners who wanted revolution to improve their lives, however a key difference is that the American revolution was sparked by outrage of political reasons whereas the french were fighting for complete social revolution., In France, an absolute monarchy, the third estate was heavily taxed, starvation was prevalent and they people wanted equality and liberty. They set in place a checks and balances system to insure that this would remain within the government. These revolutions introduced several ideas that are still in effect today, bringing democracy among other ideas to both France and the United States. The colonists wrote up the Declaration of Independence, thus beginning the war portion of the American Revolution. The French and American revolutions have similar causes such as the emphasis on, The American and French revolutions both compare and contrast in their origins and outcomes; both revolutions began due to the common peoples need to obtain independence and liberty from an oppressive government. But you can one from professional essay writers. Reason alone, unguided by history and experience, was likely to lead one into wild abstractions and the creation of an unstable government. Haiti was French colony and Latin America was spanish but independence was paramount in both and changed these areas forever. Just one last question, how similar and how different were the two of them? There were three different social groups and the lowest group, which consisted of peasants and the middle class, were burdened by heavy taxation. After the French revolution ended, Napoleon came to power, an event many deem counterintuitive as France wished to escape an autocratic government decades earlier., Before the end of the seventeenth century the French and the English had coexisted relatively peacefully in North America for nearly a century. When Louis XVI came to power, France was in deep financial trouble. In addition, the the problems that plagued the French were some of the problems that bothered the Americans. In France, although the land was large, there wasnt any body of water separating the rule. Thomas Paine published a book titled Common Sense in 1776 in which he accused the British of the detrimental effect they imposed on Americans., The American Revolution resulted directly from attempts to reform the British Empire after the Seven Years War. In France, monarchs followed a socio-political system titled the old regime, in, In contrast, while the French people wanted a change in government from a monarchy to a republic, they did not get what they fought for, instead the government became a dictatorship, the same or possibly worse that the previous monarchal situation. Overall the outcomes of independence movement in Haiti and the Spanish Americas were more different than, The French and American revolutions were two revolutions that had the mind to change the government and to set up a democracy so that everyone could have equal rights. Both revolutions also caused many people to die. The only safe path forward was to look to history and allow experience to guide their reason. Ask a professional expert to help you with your text, Enter your email below and we'll send you the sample you need right away. In the Declaration, thirteen constitutional political societies declared why it had become necessary for them to sever the political bands which had connected them to England. Francois Dominique Toussaint LOuverture was a French general and former slave, known for leading the Haitian Revolution. John Locke wrote Two Treatise of Government (1690), which posited that all men are born equal with the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and property. Locke also said that a ruler should derive their right to rule from the consent of the people, and that the people should overthrow any ruler who did not preserve the peoples unalienable rights. While ideas and perspectives may have differed in 17-1800s, it was about finding peace and prosperity as it did not exist in the colonies. European nations were greeds wanting money and control, their mistreatment were the reasons for the revolution. The major similarity they both shared were that the Revolution for both occurred in instances of the civilians rebelling against their government. % This was the case for the France, as well, which was ruled with an absolute monarchy.